West Islip, in the heart of Babylon, New York, may be a quiet, close-knit neighborhood, but don’t let its suburban calm fool you—its food scene pulses with energy, delicious tradition, and delicious surprises at nearly every turn. Whether you’re a longtime local or planning your first visit, there’s a smorgasbord of flavors waiting to greet you. Here’s your insider’s guide to the best places to eat, drink, and savor in West Islip.
Main Street Standouts: Classic West Islip Dining
Every neighborhood has its icons. In West Islip, the food destinations along Union Boulevard (Montauk Highway), Higbie Lane, and neighboring blocks have become staples for locals and foodies in-the-know.
- Primi Italian Steakhouse (999 Montauk Hwy)
Primi is synonymous with sophisticated dining in West Islip. Think dry-aged steaks, beautifully plated seafood, and a deep, thoughtful wine list. While it’s a pricier spot—entrées run from $30 to $55—the service and attention to detail make it perfect for celebrations, date nights, or simply treating yourself to the best. Don’t skip the bone-in ribeye or homemade pastas, and ask for their special tiramisu if it’s available.
- Mona Lisa Pizzeria & Ristorante (790 Udall Rd, just off Montauk Hwy)
For comforting Italian-American at a friendly price, Mona Lisa is a West Islip rite of passage. Locals rave about the thin-crust pizza, robust chicken parmigiana, and the heaping hero sandwiches. Family-friendly vibes and a takeout counter make it ideal for both weeknight dinners and casual hangouts with friends.
- Patsy’s Deli (415 Union Blvd)
No list is complete without a great deli, and Patsy’s is a go-to for overstuffed hero sandwiches, classic breakfast egg sandwiches, and homemade salads. Locally famous for their roast beef with gravy (when available!) and fresh mozzarella creations, it’s affordable, quick, and deeply rooted in the neighborhood’s daily life.
Hidden Gems: Flavors You Didn’t Expect
Beyond the mainstays, West Islip’s residential side streets and shopping corners offer real surprises—spots you might drive past without knowing what culinary treasures await.
- Misto! (Eats, Sweets & More) (397 Higbie Ln)
With a name that means “mixed” in Italian, Misto! delivers on its promise. The menu is a playful fusion of Italian, Latin, and American flavors—chicken tacos, shrimp scampi, or homemade gelato. Prices range $8–$16 for most entrées, making it both accessible and adventurous. Their breakfast sandwiches, empanadas, and inventive desserts are especially beloved by locals.
- Holy Smokes BBQ (948 Montauk Hwy)
Tucked between shops is some of Long Island’s best barbecue. Holy Smokes is a carnivore’s dream: smoky brisket, tender ribs, and a zingy house barbecue sauce. This casual spot draws a fun crowd, especially on weekends. Don’t miss their mac-and-cheese and sweet cornbread. Figure on $10–$20 for a hearty meal.
- Chico’s Tex Mex (410 Union Blvd)
A neighborhood favorite for satisfying burritos, loaded nachos, and spiced-up salads. Go for the Birria tacos or try the slightly spicy street corn. Chico’s is budget friendly (most dishes under $13), and their quick-serve style makes it perfect for grabbing food on the way to the beach.
Sweets, Sips, and More: Bakeries, Cafés, and Coffee
West Islip’s dessert and café scene is just as essential to its culinary identity as its hearty dinners. If you crave pastries, cakes, or a perfect latte, these are your must-visits:
- Buttercooky Bakery (495 Montauk Hwy)
A beloved Long Island institution, Buttercooky’s West Islip outpost is always buzzing. Their rainbow cookies, cannoli, and elaborately decorated cakes are legendary. Locals come here for holiday treats, morning coffee, and special-occasion sweets. A sweet treat will set you back $3–$7, and there’s something for every taste—classic Italian pastries to trendy cupcakes.
- West Islip Bagel Café (510 Higbie Ln)
The heart of weekend mornings. This cozy café serves hand-rolled bagels, loaded breakfast sandwiches, and fantastic cold brew coffee. Their lox and cream cheese bagel is a must-try. It’s also a hub for community gossip and early risers on weekdays.
- Mommies Ice Cream (473 Union Blvd)
Step inside this throwback shop for hand-scooped cones, thick milkshakes, and creative sundaes. Their homemade ice cream sandwiches are a summer staple for local families.
Food Trucks and Unexpected Bites
While West Islip isn’t quite Brooklyn in terms of late-night food carts, you’ll catch some standout food trucks parked at local breweries or events, especially in the summer. Look for:
- Rolling Smoke Food Truck
When nearby, this mobile kitchen brings generous smoked brisket sandwiches and Southern-style sides to the party. Check social media for their latest location—local soccer fields, West Islip beach events, and nearby brewery parking lots are typical stops.
- Coffee Booth LI
Often stationed along Higbie Lane and at local farmer’s markets, this cheery coffee truck pours luscious lattes, cold brew, and serves locally-made pastries. Perfect for a caffeine fix after a beach walk.
Local Food Traditions and Events
West Islip’s food scene isn’t just about places, but also traditions. Every spring, the neighborhood comes alive during community fairs—think apple cider donuts, hot dog stands, and fresh lemonade at Good Samaritan Hospital’s events or the local school fundraisers. The West Islip Fire Department’s annual barbecue draws crowds for its classic grilled favorites.
Pizzerias and Italian bakeries also take center stage during Christmas and Easter, when lines stretch out the door for special pastries and cookie trays. And in the summer, almost every meal seems to pair with a trip to the beach or a picnic at one of West Islip’s many parks.
Where to Start? Your Perfect Day of West Islip Eating
For a truly local experience, start with a bagel and coffee at West Islip Bagel Café, then swing by Misto! for a creative lunch. Stroll Montauk Highway for a peek at Buttercooky Bakery’s sweets, enjoy dinner at Primi or Holy Smokes (depending on your cravings), and grab a scoop at Mommies Ice Cream to end your culinary tour. Bonus points if you spot a food truck along the way.
Whether you’re after a special meal, a slice of pizza to go, or just a sweet treat, West Islip’s food scene delivers with a warm, small-town spirit and a host of seriously good eats. Don’t wait for a special occasion—make today your taste tour of West Islip.